The question is not “detect” but “and then what”
A camera sees, an alarm signals, an officer decides and acts. More often than not, the debate framed as “people or technology” is really a debate about the response: what has to happen in the five minutes after detection? If the answer is “someone has to go and look”, no technology does that on its own.
What technology does better
It does not sleep, it does not get bored, and it covers at the same moment points a person can only visit one after another. On a large site, on premises closed at night, or to keep a record you can use afterwards, it cannot be replaced. And it costs once, then it is maintained.
What people do better
They judge. They tell a late delivery from an intrusion, defuse a confrontation at reception, open a door for the emergency services. They are also a visible presence, and deterrence is not a side effect: it is often the first benefit, the one that produces no incident and therefore no statistic.
The mixed arrangement, and its trap
Combining the two is almost always the right answer — on one condition: that somebody holds the join between them. Cameras fitted by an installer, an alarm connected to one provider, officers from a third company: on the day of the incident, every one of them will have done their job and nobody will have dealt with the event. That is why the group holds the chain end to end.
How to settle it in practice
Ask yourself three questions. How long can pass between the incident and the response? Does someone have to make a judgement on site, or only record what happened? And does the site need to look deterrent? The answers shape the arrangement more reliably than a price comparison.
